Friday, December 18, 2020

Moral Panic at Dalton



It seems a lot of parents didn't know about the faculty demands until yesterday. The Naked Dollar has
 learned that the demands were originally made in August, and have somehow been kept under wraps until now. One imagines today is not a pleasant day to be a Dalton board member. The Head of School has asked parents not to contact teachers until after the break.

One parent tells me that there is zero separation between the board and the school administration. This is not surprising. Most school boards, including colleges, are now wholly owned subsidiaries of their administrations, which are, in turn, controlled by their faculties.

People want their kids to go to schools like Dalton so they can grease the Ivy League skids. Nothing wrong with that, prima facie. Dalton, for its part, needs rich kids to juice the endowment and fund all their wish list items, including diversity outreach. Nothing really wrong with that, either. 

But the rich parents play the game. They go along with every progressive fad conjured up by the administration and faculty. Many embrace them. The 1619 Project, the seventy-two genders, Critical Race Theory...it can be hard to keep up. I'm told that young Dalton kids are made to watch a PBS video called Being 12, wherein white kids are shamed for the sin of their skin color and told they are complicit in perpetuating racism. After watching the video, the white Dalton kids are asked how it "made them feel." 

How do you suppose it made them feel? As a parent, what I'm feeling is pissed off that I'm paying fifty-four grand to have my kid shamed.

A Dalton fourth grade play featured a role for a "Racist Cop." Note that the list of faculty demands insists that every school play have anti-racist narratives. So much for Our Town. I'm told even To Kill a Mockingbird is out these days. It's a white man trying to save a black man. Can't have that sort of racial paternalizing. 

In science, they are learning about "systems." Biological systems, perhaps? Ecological? No, the class features "racism" as a system. The young kids get to learn about mortgage red-lining. In science.

I could go on. This is educational malpractice of the first order.

Parents who don't buy in - and there are many - learn to keep their mouths shut. Nod and smile. Because Yale.

Those who play the game the best - and give the most - wind up on the board. This not only brings major wood to Manhattan cocktail parties - oh, to dangle those recommendation letters - but again, Yale.

So the Dalton board, which has happily gone along for the progressive ride, now finds the train has arrived at Crazy Town. After years of kowtowing to every progressive whim, they are faced with demands that are objectively impossible to meet. But how to say no? That's social suicide. Cancel city. I'm guessing the last time a board like Dalton's said no was sometime in the Pleistocene Era.

One insider I know said this: 

"Dalton is a perfect storm of narcissistic self-importance, ignorance, virtues, and empty Upper East Side values."

Ouch.

But there's one thing the board doesn't understand, something that run-of-the-mill, virtue signaling liberals never understand about revolutionary movements. (And make no mistake, that's what this is.) There is a reason that revolutionary demands are always outrageous and can't be (entirely) met: because the Revolution is the point. Leftist revolutions never, ever, say "mission accomplished" and go home. It's not how they work. If Dalton somehow did agree to everything on the list, the board would find a new list on its doorstep the next day.

To be fair, though, while Dalton is perhaps the most egregious example, what's happening there is happening everywhere. Not just schools, either. All of our institutions. Fear of cancel culture is such that our institutional leaders can't roll over fast enough. Statements of obeisance are made, indulgences paid. Mea culpas made for thought crimes never committed.

When will the culture start pushing back? Will it start with Dalton parents? Doubtful, but who knows?

Later today, this site will post the full faculty letter, because apparently some people think this is being made up, or that it's meant to be satire. It's not.

Stay tuned.


9 comments:

  1. Can you elaborate on what it looks like to "push back" ? Does it look like the 1950s ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I imagine it would start with firing the faculty.

      Delete
    2. On what basis, and replacing them with who? More arrogant white people like yourself?

      Delete
    3. More arrogant white people like yourself?

      Thanks for the projection. Been an education.


      On the basis that they're not interested in imparting knowledge and skills to students, that they want to waste revenue on malicious zero-marginal-product employees, and that they're jonesing to continue an effort to saddle the institution with an architectonic mission that is contrived and inane. This isn't that difficult.

      Delete
  2. About the "parent" who said "As a parent, what I'm feeling is pissed off that I'm paying fifty-four grand to have my kid shamed.", First of all this wasn't a quote so I can assume that this is either not a parent, or it's paraphrased, but what reason would you have to paraphrase only to make it fit your narrative better. Also, if you watch the actual video, "Being 12" white kids are not being shamed for their privilege, it is actually the opposite. Children of color are sharing stories of being shamed by white kids. There is one white girl who talks about how she feels guilty because of the privilege she has but does not deserve. What I'm trying to point out is the irony that the video is pointing out how white students are making students of color feel bad because of their differences, whether that be skin color, ancestry, or cultural identity, but when the roles are reversed, instead of being viewed as a micro-aggression, it is pissing off parents because their kids are "being shamed". Just another example of a double standard that goes overlooked by white parents at a private school like Dalton.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Completely agreed.

      Mr. Johnston, as a conservative myself and as you've seemingly taken it upon yourself to "report" on this "urgent", "highly important" issue of which you have no actual affiliation to— I must ask, what does your ideal outcome look like here? People are just "silenced", and any civil discussion is just ended? That certainly doesn't sound very conservative to me.

      Delete
    2. Conveniently, there is no mention of WHO is shaming the children of color as a result of their differences. Likely it is students in general, which could and probably does include black students. It has been my experience that black people are the most racist and first to comment on differences. White kids (white people in general) have been shamed over the years to know better than to say anything about race to a black kid.

      Delete
  3. I also choose to send my kid to a fancy private school. However, a Catholic fancy private school. No, it is not immune to the vagaries of the Equalicist proclamations, but it is comprised mostly of sober minded parents diametrically opposed to this classist nonsense. We gladly give up a few seats in each class to underprivileged, tuition paid for by the rest of us, collectively, but we will never subscribe to this nonsense.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Parents pay through the nose to send their kids to a Dalton because they want the best shot at getting into a Harvard, Yale, or Princeton. Princeton's not going to be taking as many kids from Dalton once Dalton eliminates all advanced courses because black kids don't perform equally to white kids in those classes, as demanded in the manifesto.

    ReplyDelete